http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/2008/9/7/details-on-cave-scene-events-on-astronomy-tower-from-hbp-screening

WTF? Most of it sounds fantastic, but this one little scene......


{Meanwhile under the floor Harry who is watching terrified with his wand at the ready is sneaked up on by Snape, whose wand is also out and puts his finger to his lips to make sure Harry stays quiet. My description does not quite capture that scene well enough, but I was surprised to find my heart ripping, perhaps because I knew what was going to happen when Snape appeared there. Snape quietly appears above, and Dumbledore, with far too much strength says “Severus Please.”}


No invisibility cloak! As if Harry is just going to obey Snape and stand there.  The minute Dumbleass went flying off the tower, Harry would have been screaming and hexing everything in sight.  Bella would have Ak'd Harry and Greyback could have snacked on him instead of Bill. End of story!
Go to the Link to read the whole report at Leaky
.

Profile

dixiebell: (Default)
dixiebell
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags